Our Menu

Blankcanvas3 transition2
*Can be made gluten free
**Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness

Primi

Italian Chopped Salad*
Romaine, radicchio, red onion, celery, cherry tomatoes, pepperoncini peppers, sun dried tomatoes, provolone, chickpeas, Italian vinaigrette
$19
Caesar Salad *
Romaine hearts tossed in house-made caesar dressing, topped with fried capers, white anchovies, and a side of fontina croutons
$18
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
House spices, pancetta, lemon juice
$19
Tomato + Burrata
Balsamic glaze, basil, extra virgin olive oil
$20
Isola Meatballs
Blended meats, house made rustic pomodoro, parmesan
$18
Arancini Quatro Formaggi
Fried risotto croquettes with pomodoro
$18
Isola Wings
Your choice of calabrian garlic or house buffalo, served with carrot ribbons, celery, and gorgonzola dolce dip
$16

Piatti

Bistecca
grilled 14 oz. NY strip with seasonal vegetables with side of peppercorn sauce
$42
Fish of the Day
Ask your server
MP
Crispy Eggplant Parmesan
bucatini, house made rustic pomodoro and mozzarella
$24
Crispy Chicken Parmesan
bucatini, house made rustic pomodoro and mozzarella
$26
Isola Burger * **
8oz chuck burger, romaine lettuce, brioche bun, and choice of parmesan truffle fries or side salad
Add cheddar, mozzarella, gorgonzola, sauteed mushrooms, tomato, caramelized onions, + $2ea.
Add bacon, + $3
$18

Sides

Spaghetti & Pomodoro
$10
Mixed Green Salad
$10
Seasonal Veggies
$12
Add Shrimp (4)
$14
Add Grilled Chicken
$10
Add Salmon
Spaghetti and house-made pomodoro sauce
$15
Add Meatballs (3)
Mixed greens with house-made roasted tomato vinaigrette
$8

Pasta

Gnocchi con Funghi
House made fresh gnocchi with ricotta, roasted mushroom mix, green peas, brown butter and sage
$28
Orecchiette con Salsiccia
fresh orecchiette pasta with sweet Italian sausage and broccoli rabe
$26
Carbonara
pancetta, parmesan, cream, fried egg
$26
Old Style Bolognese*
house made pappardelle, parmesan, pomodoro, carrots
$26
Macaroni Isola
béchamel sauce, English peas, pancetta, truffle oil, panko
$24
Penne all a Vodka
vodka reduction with heavy cream, parmesan, pomodoro, caramalized onion, and crushed red pepper
$22
Spaghetti Pomodoro
Spaghetti tossed in house-made pomodoro sauce.
Add 3 meatballs, + $8
$18

Wood-Fired Pizza

Margherita
Prepared in our wood-fire oven with pomodoro sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil
$20
Calabrese
Prepared in our wood-fire oven with pomodoro sauce, fresh mozzarella, and spicy calabrian salami
$22
Nuvola
White pie, prepared in our wood-fire oven with mozzarella, ricotta fresca, parmigiano, and provolone, drizzled with truffle honey and sprinkled with thyme
$25
BPT
Prepared in our wood-fire oven with pomodoro sauce, mozzarella, applewood smoked bacon, sun dried tomatoes, hot cherry peppers, and basil
$25
Create Your Own
choose a pizza base from above with your choice of toppings below:
  • $2 each: Garlic,Extracheese,Extrasauce Green olives, Red onion
  • $3 each: Bacon, Farm egg, Anchovies, Kalamata olives, Sun-dried tomatoes, Cherry peppers
  • $4 each:Meatball,Arugulasalad, Mushrooms, Fennel sausage, Vegan mozzarella
$---

Bambini

Spaghetti Pomodoro
$13
Breaded Chicken Breast
served with fries
$13
Spaghetti with Butter
$13
Creamy Mac ‘n’ Cheese
$13

Drinks

Coke
$3
Diet Coke
$3
Ginger Ale
$3
Sprite
$3
Shirley Temple
$5

Desserts

Creamy Panna Cotta
with vanilla and fruit topping
$14
Tiramisu for Two
$16
Cocktails
Isola features a full and lively bar will a full compliment of liquor, beer and wines.  An island favorite, Isola’s bar is a fun place to have a drink or eat your dinner.  There is plenty of space including bar tables and long comfortable bar. 

Cocktails

Jalepeno Ginger Margarita
Jalepeño infused tequila, fresh citrus mix, ginger liqueur, orange liqueur, ginger beer
$17
Isola Spritz
Prosecco, elderflower liqueur, rose water, lemon juice, lemon twist
$17
Aperol Spritz
Aperol, prosecco, orange slice
$18
Dark & Stormy
Gosling's rum, ginger beer, lime
$17
Isola Old Fashioned
Bourbon, demerara, angostura bitters, muddled cherry and orange
$17
Peach Cosmopolitan
Vodka, peach schnapps, lime
$17
Negroni Spagliato
Campari, sweet vermouth, sparkling wine
$17
Black Manhattan
Bourbon or rye, angostura bitters, amaro, black cherry 
$17

Dessert Cocktails

Espresso Martini
Vanilla vodka, kahlua, fresh brewed espresso 
$19
Cappuccino Martini
Vanilla vodka, kahlua, bailey's, fresh brewed espresso  
$19
Chocolate Martini
Vodka, cacao liqueur, chocolate syrup, chocolate sprinkles 
$19

BEER & WINE

*Bottle Only

Sparkling

Prosecco ‘20
Stellina di Notte, Italy
$15
Champagne Brut Reserve Cuvée*
Veuve Clicquot, Champagne, France
$90

Rose

Vin de Provence ‘20
Juliette la Sangliere, France
$12
Cotes de Provence ‘20
Whispering Angel, France
$18

White

Gavi ‘19
San Matteo, Italy
$17
Pinot Grigio ‘21
Bollini, Trentino, Northeastern Italy
$14
Sauvignon Blanc ‘21
Matua, New Zealand
$12
Chardonnay ‘20
Josh, California
$15

Red

Pinot Noir ‘19
Firesteed, Oregon
$15
Barbera d’Alba ‘20
Franco Amoroso, Alba, Italy
$15
Montepulciano ‘18
Gio Barba, Italy
$17
Chianti ‘19
Banfi, Tuscany, italy
$15
Cabernet Sauvignon ‘19
Prophecy, California
$15
Super Tuscan ‘19
Donnaolimpia 1898, Italy
$17
Nero d’Avola ‘18
Feudo Maccari, Italy
$17

Beer

Bottles + Cans
  • Bud Light $5
  • Budweiser $5
  • Michelob Ultra $7
  • Narragansett $7
  • Guinness $8
  • Brooklyn Effects $7 (Non-alcoholic)
Draft
  • Peroni $8
  • Montauk Wave
  • Chaser $9
  • Shelter Island Brewery IPA $8
  • Warsteiner German Pilsner $9
Image